Best Crib Mattress Pad For Adorable Babies 2023 [Buying Guide]

baby lying in his crib

If you’re in a hurry and just looking for the best crib mattress pad, then the SureGuard Crib Mattress Protector is the best one.

Babies spend about two-thirds of their day sleeping. Thus, it is only natural as a parent to want to give them as much comfort as possible.

This ensures the most satisfying sleep for newborns to keep them healthy and happy.

A crib mattress cover or a crib mattress pad is one of the smartest ways to ensure your baby sleeps in luxury. Also, these covers protect babies from various kinds of accidents.

Unfortunately, many parents struggle to choose the right model for their babies. This is usually due to the thousands of options available from different manufacturers.

If you’re in a similar situation at the moment then this is your lucky day.

We’ve compiled the list of the top crib mattress pads available for sale right now.

We’ve also created the most complete crib mattress pad/cover buying guide for you below. It features a whole lot of tips and tricks to make the search process as easy as possible.

Follow the tips outlined in the guide below to make the right choice during shopping.

How To Choose The Best Crib Mattress Cover

Parents desire the highest levels of comfort and protection for their babies. This is because these little ones need to rest easy to be able to grow healthy and happy.

Unfortunately, there are tons of options available. Hence, finding the best pads for crib mattresses can become very problematic.

Here are the tips and tricks necessary if you want to end up with a mattress cover your baby can grow with. These tips will also maintain that adorable baby’s health and happiness.


The type of material used is probably the most important consideration during shopping.

Choosing a model derived from a quality organic material such as cotton terry can be a wise option. Cotton is famous for serving babies needs well for a long time

Whichever material you choose, make sure it is soft and breathable. This can guarantee the baby’s comfort during hotter times of the year.

Additionally, the material should be completely hypoallergenic. It should also be chemical-free and organic.

Always make sure the material is GOTS, CERTIPUR-US, or OEKO-TEX-certified. These certifications come from reputable organizations to prove quality and environmental friendliness.

Easy To Wash & Dry

Even the best crib mattress pads get messy. Thus, choosing a model that is easy to wash and dry can be convenient in many ways.

The good news is that the majority of the models available for sale today are machine washable. Throw dirty covers into a washing machine once it gets dirty and it will look like new again.

Lastly, always read and follow any washing instructions the manufacturer provides. This can preserve the lifespan of the mattress cover and ensure more benefits for your baby.

Silent and Quiet

Babies need the plushest sleeping surfaces to enjoy their sleep. This is why buying a model that feels soft on the skin is so important.

Avoid mattress covers that provide crinkling noises with each baby movement. This is because they can be a recipe for disaster.

Choosing an ultra-quiet crib mattress cover guarantees a great sleeping experience for newborns.

The good news is that the softer the pad, the less noise it makes.

Hence, all you have to do is to choose an ultra-soft mattress cover. This should enhance your baby’s ability to sleep without interruptions.


Your costs can add up quickly whenever a new baby comes into the family. This is why we recommend buying a comfortable yet durable baby mattress pad.

Sure, the best baby mattress pads may be more expensive than inferior models. But, their durability can provide more value for your money in the long run.

Don’t forget to order a waterproof model that offers protection from liquids. But make sure none of the features stands in the way of its ability to help your baby sleep cool.

Also, avoid buying the cheapest crib mattress covers especially when money is tight. This is because such models are likely to unravel after a few weeks or months of use.

You wouldn’t want to have to pay for another baby mattress pad anytime soon, would you?

Good Grip

A few things can be more frustrating than a mattress pad that moves and shifts while your baby is sleeping.

First of all, this can be downright uncomfortable for the sleeping baby. Also, it can lead to accidental seeping of liquids such as urine onto the crib mattress.

Fortunately, the latest models on the market feature world-class slip resistance.

In any case, it is important to delve deeper into each prospective model. This will help you make a well-informed choice.

The Best Crib Mattressess

SureGuard Crib Mattress Protector

This is one of the best-selling covers on the market. No wonder it continues to attract stellar ratings from new parents and grandparents. 

SureGuard Mattress Protectors Crib Size - 100% Waterproof, Hypoallergenic - Premium Fitted Cotton Terry Cover - 10 Year Warranty

It can be a smart buy if you’re committed to finding the best bedding for your beloved bundle of joy.

The SureGuard Protector features Cotton Terry material renowned for its quality and comfort.

It offers effective protection against everyday liquids ranging from water to urine. This is thanks to its tried and tested 100 percent waterproof properties.

Additionally, it repels dirt and all kinds of stains.

The result is a crib mattress cover that stays clean and fresh throughout its lifetime.

The ability to wick away moisture is another outstanding feature of the SureGuard. Also, it retains the look and feel of your child’s mattress in a soft and noise-free manner.

Furthermore, this mattress pad is easy to clean and built to last longer than the competition. This is in spite of the anticipated heavy usage.

Finally, it is naturally hypoallergenic meaning it blocks all manner of harmful allergens. This protects babies from dust mites, bacteria, mold, and mildew.

Check Price on Amazon


Jambini Waterproof Crib Mattress Cover

The Jambini Fully Encased Crib Mattress Cover offers a crafted layer of soft padding.

Jambini Zipper Crib Mattress Protector - Fully Encased & Waterproof Cover

The amazing cushioning this cover offers enables babies to sleep longer and deeper.

Indeed, placing this toddler mattress pad on his or her bed guarantees a cozier sleep.

This mattress cover encases the entire length and breadth of existing crib mattresses.

Thus, it prevents exposure of any parts. Also, many new parents say they appreciate the hypoallergenic properties of this model.

Can you imagine laying your baby on a cover that naturally repels 99 percent of allergens daily?

The Jambini sleeps completely noise-free unlike the majority of baby crib mattress pads.

Hence, your child can stretch and move his or her body as much as necessary without any interruptions.

Also, the manufacturer offers protection for your child’s health and safety at all times. This is why this crib mattress cover is free from harmful chemicals.

In fact, it is devoid of phthalates, vinyl, PVC, fire retardants, and other toxic chemicals.

Check Price on Amazon


PUREgrace Crib Mattress Protector

The PUREgrace Crib Mattress Protector takes plush baby sleeping to unimaginable levels.

PUREgrace Crib Mattress Protector (28" x 52

It sports a 100 percent natural Tencel cover to offer a world-class layer of luxury. The eucalyptus-based Tencel fibers are also completely hypoallergenic.

Hence, it can be the perfect option for babies with sensitive skins to sleep smooth.

This crib mattress cover is strong and durable in spite of the amazingly soft feel.

You can wash it as many times as possible with the guarantee that the soft layer stays in its original shape.

This cover stays free of brunching, shrinking, and other common structural depreciation.

The PUREgrace Protector fits all standard crib mattresses. This is thanks to its deep-pocketed corners reinforced for extra safety.

Thus, your beloved baby gets to sleep for many hours to wake up energized. He or she also stay protected from potential accidents.

This crib mattress offers waterproof protection for babies. We love the fact that it does not contain chemicals such as BPA, PVC, VINYL, and Phthalates.

This eliminates all kinds of plastic smells and protects babies from toxic chemicals.

The PUREgrace is the best waterproof crib mattress cover money can buy at the moment.

Check Price on Amazon



Little One’s Pad Crib Mattress Cover

Looking for a quality crib mattress cover for portable baby cribs and play yards? This model could be a solid choice!

Little One's Pad Pack N Play Crib Mattress Cover - 27" X 39

The Little One’s Pad Pack N Play Crib Mattress Cover is a must-have if you own any kind of portable/mini crib mattress. It is also perfect for all kinds of foldable baby mattresses.

It feels very soft on a baby’s skin and easy to clean without compromising his or her comfort during sleep.

Besides, this crib mattress pad comprises strong, reinforced threads with industry-leading fibers. It also features world-class waterproof lining as well as other innovative technologies.

The result is a soft, comfortable, and durable crib cover that is sure to last for many years.

It never shrinks or suffers any physical deterioration. Also, it stays in shape after hundreds of washing and drying cycles.

The super-soft quilted peach microfiber material top absorbs all kinds of liquids.

Thus, you can expect the utmost comfort for your baby. It also provides extra protection for that expensive existing crib mattress.

A restful and soothing sleep awaits your beloved baby!

Check Price on Amazon


iLuvBamboo Crib Mattress Pad Protector

The iLuvBamboo Crib Mattress Pad Protector can be a worthwhile buy. If your baby’s comfort is of the utmost concern, you cannot brush it off any longer.

iLuvBamboo Crib Mattress Pad Protector (Mom’s Choice Gold Award Winner) Waterproof Cover -Soft Bamboo Jacquard Fitted Topper - Quiet, Breathable & Smooth -Potty Training Toddlers & Infants Baby Gifts

The first property you notice is how soft and cozy this mattress protector feels. Many parents say they’re tempted to place their babies on it and forgo bed sheets altogether.

This crib mattress cover is breathable, easy to wash, and waterproof.

It also features extra-deep dimensions making it easy to encase around crib mattresses.

Are you tired of inferior quality mattress pads that make disturbing plastic noises? The iLuvBamboo Crib Mattress Pad Protector will be a welcome relief.

Additionally, it offers tried and tested levels of durability.

The manufacturer’s lifetime “better than money-back guarantee” backs every single sale. This gives you the confidence to order at no risk.

Check Price on Amazon


I’m A Little Teapot Organic Cotton Crib Pad

I’m A Little Teapot GOTS Organic Cotton Crib Mattress Pad is another popular option for crib mattresses.

GOTS Organic Cotton Crib Mattress Pad Protector - Waterproof Cover - Fitted & Quilted with Cotton no Polyester - Ultra Soft & Durable

It features a natural cotton top, natural cotton filling, and natural cotton skirt.

Touching it reveals the quality of this waterproof baby crib mattress cover.

This cover feels plush and luxurious. Why do you think it continues to receive so many raving reviews from consumers?

Many current owners confess loving the fact that it is easy to wash. Also, it doesn’t ship with confusing laundry instructions like rival models.

This GOTS Crib Mattress stays in great shape for a long time. This is evident even after hundreds of washing and drying sessions.

Also, the built-in organic cotton sides result in minimal risk of dryer shredding.

The premium cotton-filled quilting adds the right amount of luxury and comfort.

Additionally, every inch of cotton used is GOTS certified organic. This adds to the long list of impressive features this model offers.

Thus, you can trust that there are zero traces of artificial cotton and other toxic chemicals.

Check Price on Amazon


Luxuriously Soft Bamboo Crib Mattress Cover

The Luxuriously Soft Bamboo Crib Mattress Cover by Bebe Owl is another solid option for parents. It provides the most amazing baby sleeping experiences.

Luxuriously Soft Bamboo Crib Mattress Cover by Bebe Owl, Quilted White Waterproof Protector for Standard Sized Baby & Toddler Mattresses - Super Absorbent, Durable and Easy to Wash

It features premium quality bamboo velour material renowned for its softness. The velour provides extra plushness compared to the bamboo used in cheap crib mattress pads.

This mom-designed waterproof mattress offers a first-hand perspective of babies needs. So, the construction and finish factor your little one’s every need.

No wonder many babies fall in love with this model right from day one.

The Crib Mattress Cover is rigorously tested and OEKO-TEX certified. Hence, you can buy with confidence knowing that it is free from any harmful chemicals.

This protects your baby from exposure to toxic chemicals with dangerous side effects.

Bebe Owl is sure that your little one will enjoy this mattress cover.

Thus, they’re happy to offer a hassle-free refund guarantee for all returns.

Check Price on Amazon


Benefits of The Best Crib Mattress Pads

It is no secret that healthy and comfortable babies sleep a lot at the infancy stage. As such, regular crib mattresses can be under a lot of pressure.

The fact that they’re used several hours every single day puts them at risk of significant wear and tear.

Hence, a quality crib mattress pad or cover can come in handy. It protects that costly crib mattress to maximize value for money.

These mattress covers also keep babies more comfortable.

Here are a few reasons why a great crib mattress cover is a must-buy for every new parent.


Waterproof Protection

We all know that babies produce a lot of liquids, especially during their early months and years. Vomit, pee, and poo become a central part of their lives at this delicate moment and there are no two ways around them.

These liquids can lead to many health problems if allowed to make contact with your baby’s crib mattress.

Thankfully, many crib mattress pads on the market today sports built-in waterproof linings.

This lining provides extra protection against liquids by quickly wicking away moisture. If your little one suffers an accident, cleaning up becomes much easier.

The best waterproof crib mattress covers prevent liquids from soiling existing crib mattress. This protects against the development of molds and mildew.

Remember, molds and mildew can pose a serious threat to the health of your baby. They can also affect the physical look and feel of that expensive crib mattress.

Quick and Breezy Clean-Up Time

Sure, there’s no magical solution to preventing young babies from suffering accidents. But the right crib mattress pad makes it easy to clean them up.

Always make sure to buy mattress pads that are machine washable. Also, the prospective model should be easy to dry without any fuzzy instructions.

We recommend buying 2 or 3 separate mattress covers to provide round-the-clock protection. This ensures that your baby’s crib mattress stays protected even when one or 2 covers are dirty.

Protection Against Common Bacteria and Allergens

A crib mattress cover can serve as a line of defense against bacteria and dust mites.

It is no secret that babies have delicate immune systems during the early stages. Hence, the bacteria and dust mite protection can be a lifesaver in so many ways.

Hypoallergenic crib mattress pads can protect your bundle of joy from harmful microorganisms. They also protect infants from avoidable allergies.

World-class allergen protection can also be very helpful for babies with sensitive skins. It can be the secret to preventing rashes, itchy skins, and other forms of discomfort.

The absence of these blemishes usually helps babies to grow healthy and happy.


A crib mattress pad or cover can be a smart and cheap way to protect an expensive baby mattress.

The right model can also ensure that your beloved bundle of joy enjoys his sleep.

We believe that the SureGuard Protector is the best crib mattress cover on the market at this moment.

It is affordable and offers world-class features including 100 percent waterproof protection. Also, it comprises organic cotton material and provides exceptional hypoallergenic properties.

Additionally, it feels easy to fit on any crib mattress.

Have any questions or thoughts on any of the best crib mattress pad reviews above? Feel free to leave a comment here.

Gabriel Smith

Hello, my name is Gabriel and I LOVE to sleep. Okay, you’re right, a lot of people do like sleep. But my passion is actually not sleeping. My interest lies in the “theoretical part”. What to do before bedtime. What a good night’s sleep is. etc. In short, how to sleep well. I hope you share the same interest as me, and enjoy reading everything about sleep.

Recent Posts